Answer guide

How to answer “Tell me about a decision you made with incomplete information”

Keep the story simple. Show what you knew, which missing information mattered most and how you went to get it, the fallback if it never came, how you weighed the options, and that you made the call yourself.

Practise this question out loud →

What the interviewer is really listening for

  • Your own judgment. Did you decide, or wait for someone else to?
  • Information gathering. How did you get the most important missing facts?
  • A fallback. What would you do without them?
  • Clean story. Is it easy to follow?

Common mistakes

A messy, long story

Keep to one decision and the key facts.

Someone else decided

Show your own reasoning and call.

No reflection

Say how it turned out and what you'd change.

A structure that works: what you knew, what you sought, how you decided, result

  1. What you knewThe decision and the information available.
  2. What you soughtThe key missing facts and how you went to get them.
  3. How you decidedOptions, trade-offs, fallback, the call.
  4. The resultWhat happened, and what you learned.

Example answers

These examples are invented to show the structure. Use your own facts and your own words; a memorised answer sounds memorised.

Supply-chain planner
What you knew

A supplier warned of a possible strike, but couldn't say if or when it would start.

What you sought

I asked their account manager for daily updates and checked how much stock we held of the five affected parts.

How you decided

I compared waiting, splitting the next order with a second supplier, or buying three months' stock, and chose to split the order because it was reversible.

The result

The strike happened for ten days; we had no stock-outs and paid about 4 percent more for the split order.

School head of department
What you knew

I had to choose an exam board for a new course before the full syllabus was published.

What you sought

I called two other schools already piloting it and the board's adviser to get the draft assessment details.

How you decided

I chose the board whose draft matched our teachers' strengths, with a plan to switch in the first term if the final syllabus changed.

The result

The final syllabus barely changed, and first-year results were above our average.

Follow-up questions to expect

  • How do you know when you have enough information?
  • What would you have done without that call?
  • Tell me about a decision that went wrong.

Other ways this is asked

Is this like "Tell me about a time you had to make a quick decision"?

Similar. Shorten the information-gathering part and focus on the trade-off.

Say it out loud, then see what to fix

Reading a guide is not the same as answering under pressure. Practise this question and get feedback on each part of your answer, the way an interviewer would hear it.

Practise “Tell me about a decision you made with incomplete information” →