Answer guide
How to answer “Tell me about a significant disagreement with a colleague”
Choose a real disagreement about the work, explain both views fairly, and show how you kept emotion out, focused on the result, and resolved it yourself so the work kept moving.
Practise this question out loud →What the interviewer is really listening for
- Focus on the work. Did you deal with the issue rather than the person?
- Professional calm. Did you keep emotion out of it?
- Resolve it yourself. Could you handle it, or did you need someone else every time?
- Perspective. Do you see disagreement as a normal part of work?
Common mistakes
Making the other person the villain
Describe their view fairly; it shows maturity.
Escalating immediately
Show what you tried yourself first.
No outcome
Say how the work turned out and how the relationship is now.
A structure that works: disagreement, both views, how you resolved it, result
- The disagreementWhat the work was and what you disagreed on.
- Both viewsYour position and theirs, fairly.
- How you resolved itThe conversation or step that moved it forward.
- The resultWhat happened to the work and the relationship.
Example answers
These examples are invented to show the structure. Use your own facts and your own words; a memorised answer sounds memorised.
A colleague and I disagreed about moving handover from the bedside to the nurses' station during busy shifts.
She felt bedside handover took too long; I worried we'd miss details we could see at the bedside.
Instead of debating it, I suggested we try her approach for two weeks and track anything missed.
We found two near-misses, agreed on bedside handover only for high-risk patients, and she now leads that checklist.
A designer and I disagreed about a campaign layout two days before launch.
I wanted more product detail; he wanted a cleaner page.
I stopped arguing about taste and asked what the page needed to achieve, then we agreed to test both versions with a small audience.
His version won on clicks, mine on sign-ups, so we combined them and launched on time.
Follow-up questions to expect
- What would you do differently?
- How is your relationship with that person now?
- What if you couldn't agree at all?
Other ways this is asked
Is this the same as "working with a difficult person"?
Close, but here the focus is one disagreement about the work. The difficult-person question is about an ongoing relationship.
Can I use a disagreement with a client?
Yes, if the question allows it, but a colleague is safer because that's what they asked.
Say it out loud, then see what to fix
Reading a guide is not the same as answering under pressure. Practise this question and get feedback on each part of your answer, the way an interviewer would hear it.
Practise “Tell me about a significant disagreement with a colleague” →