Answer guide

How to answer “Tell me about a time you disagreed with your manager”

Show that you raised your view with reasons, made an effort to understand your manager's position, and then helped make the final direction work, whichever way it went.

Practise this question out loud →

What the interviewer is really listening for

  • Initiative. Do you speak up when you have a view?
  • Curiosity, not suspicion. Did you try to understand their reasoning?
  • Followership. Once a decision was made, did you support it?

Common mistakes

Telling a story where the manager looks foolish

Show respect for their position even if you still disagree.

"I just did what I was told"

Show you raised your view first.

Going around your manager

Explain how you worked it out with them directly.

A structure that works: your view, their view, the decision, how you helped

  1. Your viewWhat you proposed and why.
  2. Their viewWhat you learned when you asked about their reasoning.
  3. The decisionWhat was decided.
  4. How you helpedWhat you did to make the outcome work.

Example answers

These examples are invented to show the structure. Use your own facts and your own words; a memorised answer sounds memorised.

Retail store supervisor
Your view

I suggested we close the fitting rooms an hour earlier on weekdays to cover restocking.

Their view

My manager disagreed, and when I asked why, she explained that evening shoppers had the highest spend per visit.

The decision

We kept the fitting rooms open.

How you helped

I reorganised restocking into two shorter blocks instead, which kept shelves full without losing evening sales.

Software engineer
Your view

I pushed to rewrite a payment module before adding a new feature to it.

Their view

My manager wanted the feature first; when I asked, I learned a large customer contract depended on the date.

The decision

We shipped the feature first, with a rewrite planned for the next quarter.

How you helped

I wrote the tests that would make the rewrite safer, and we started it on schedule.

Follow-up questions to expect

  • What if you still thought you were right?
  • How often do you disagree with your manager?
  • What would your manager say about you?

Other ways this is asked

What if my manager was clearly wrong?

Say what you did to raise it and the result. Avoid sounding bitter; interviewers picture you saying the same about them.

Say it out loud, then see what to fix

Reading a guide is not the same as answering under pressure. Practise this question and get feedback on each part of your answer, the way an interviewer would hear it.

Practise “Tell me about a time you disagreed with your manager” →